Session Summary

Session Number:296
Session ID:S153
Session Title:Closing the Revolving Door: Turnover and Retention
Short Title:Turnover and Retention
Session Type:Shared Interest Track Paper
Hotel:Hyatt East
Floor:LL2
Room:GndBall C(N)
Time:Wednesday, August 11, 1999 10:40 AM - 12:00 PM

Sponsors

HCM  (Jacqueline Zinn)zinn@vm.temple.edu (215) 204-1684 
HR  (Lynn Shore)mgtlms@langate.gsu.edu (404) 651-3038 
IM  (Farok Contractor)farok@andromeda.rutgers.edu (973) 353-5348 
OB  (Robert Liden)bobliden@uic.edu (312) 996-4481 

General People

Facilitator Hom, Peter W.  Arizona State U. peter.hom@asu.edu 602-965-6466 

Submissions

Testing the Impact of Job Search and Recruitment Source on Employee Turnover in a Maquiladora 
 Linnehan, Frank  Drexel U. linnehf@drexel.edu (215) 895-2122 
 Blau, Gary J. Temple U. gblau@sbm.temple.edu 215-204-6906 
 Using a sample of 345 Mexican maquiladora workers, this study tested the impact of prepatory and active job search behavior scales, and U.S. and Mexican recruitment source measures on employee turnover. Beyond controlled-for variables, active job search and U.S. recruitment source measures were found to have significant, positive relationships to employee turnover. These findings seem partially explained by the extended Mexican family culture and point to the conclusion that careful consideration of Mexican culture is needed to enhance the successful growth of international firms in Mexico.
 Keywords: job search; maquiladora; recruitment
Work Experience and Opportunities: Turnover Decisions Among Medical Employees in Isreal 
 Mano-Negrin, Rita  Haifa University rsso155@haifa.uvm.ac.il none 
 Kirschenbaum, Alan  Technion, Israel Institute of Technology avik@techunix.technion.ac.il none 
 A retrospective analysis of turnover behavior among medical personnel in Isreal is conceptualized as the outcome of a two-fold time dimension effect: (a) previous work experiences reflecting duration spent in past organizational/occupational positions and b) present evaluation of alternative employment positions. Four medical occupational groups from 8 medical institutionslocated in seven geographic areas in Isreal, and a follow-up sample of 80 voluntary employee withdraws was used to demonstrate that variations in past work-event history and present occupational organizational opportunities generate occupational level differences in employees' opportunities preceding actual turnover behavior.
 Keywords: health organizations; career opportunities; turnover
Person-Organization Fit: The Match Between Newcomers' and Recruiters' Preferences For Organizational Cultures 
 Van Vianen, Annelies Elizabeth Amsterdam university ao_vianen@macmail.psy.uva.nl (+31)205256856 
 This study examined the effects of three measures of fit on newcomers’ commitment and turnover intentions. Newcomers preferences for organizational cultures were compared with their perceptions of existing organizational culture (subjective P-O fit), with their recruiters’ perceptions of organizational culture (objective P-O fit) and with recruiters’ preferences for organizational culture (P-P fit). Culture preferences and supplies concerned four dimensions of organizational culture: Human relations, rational goal, regulation and innovation. Results revealed that both newcomers’ perceptions of organizational culture and P-P fit with their supervisor were related to organizational commitment and turnover intentions. Fit between newcomers’ and supervisor’s preferences for the human relations dimension of organizational culture accounted for a substantial part of the variance in commitment and turnover intentions.
 Keywords: Person-Organization Fit; Culture Preferences; Newcomers
The Retention of Employees: The Role of Organizational Embeddedness 
 Mitchell, Terence R. U. of Washington trm@u.washington.edu (206)-543-6779 
 Holtom, Brooks C. U. of Washington holtomb@u.washington.edu (206) 484-0725 
 Lee, Thomas W. U. of Washington orcas@u.washington.edu 206-543-4389 
 Erez, Miriam  Technion, Israel Institute of Technology merez@ie.technion.ac.il 972-4-294461 
 Sablynski, Chris J. U. of Washington chrissab@u.washington.edu (206) 543-4367 
 This paper introduces a new construct, called organizational embeddedness, which we believe is a key factor in understanding why people stay in their jobs. There are some important aspects of this construct that differentiate it from constructs such as job satisfaction, job involvement and organizational commitment. In particular, organizational embeddedness is broader in its focus. It includes work and non-work aspects. We conceptualize organizational embeddedness as having three distinct dimensions--links, fit, and sacrifice. In measuring this new construct, we tried to capture the extent to which a person had links to other people or activities, the extent to which the job and organization fit with other aspects in the person’s life space and the ease with which links could be broken--what the person would sacrifice, or give up, if he or she left. Using two, large independent samples, we found empirical support for the theorized factor structure of organizational embeddedness and its ability to predict intention to leave. Importantly, we also found embeddedness adds substantial information to our understanding of employee retention over and above that contributed by job satisfaction, job involvement, or organizational commitment. In sum, we believe that by considering more comprehensively the work and non-work factors that influence a person’s decision to remain in an organization, organizational embeddedness may be instructive to professionals trying to manage employee retention in an increasingly pluralistic world.
 Keywords: retention; turnover